Archive for October, 2008

Oct 31 2008

Following up on Focus Groups

Published by jennk under ADLT 602

This past week in class we discussed focus groups and interviews. I’ll agree with Dr. Carter that I also like these qualitative forms of evaluation compared to quantitative. I was a mass communications major for a reason…. numbers and I don’t go well together.

Learning about evaluation over the past few weeks has made me realize that I’ve had experience with some but it’s still very minimal. The one focus group I have been involved in was during the School of Mass Communications accreditation process. I was picked to sit in on a focus group to talk about our experiences, classes, professors, etc. in the program. I remember feeling very comfortable during the interview, however I was hesitant to express my true feelings about some issues within the school. I also felt like we were apart of an infomercial raving about the School of Mass Communications good points and no one wanted to say the slightest thing wrong.

Looking back on it, I think my hesitation was similar to what we discussed in class, that you never know what people may say when they walk out the door. Yes, everyone can say they won’t repeat things that have been said but there is never that 100% confidentiality. With this being said, I know I still prefer focus groups and interviews as a model of collecting data and with the program I’m planning I think a focus group would be most beneficial.

On a side note… Happy Halloween everyone!

No responses yet

Oct 21 2008

Evaluation on my Tuesday:

Published by jennk under ADLT 602

I thought it was quite comical when I realized how much evaluation played a part in my everyday life. Not only do I read and think about it each week, especially in Dr. Abrams class, but now I’m also surrounded by it at work. I logged into Lotus Notes this morning to see that I had not one, not two, but three surveys/evaluation’s awaiting my response.

  • VCU Department of Business: Survey Invitation for the VCU Community
  • Thermo Fisher Scientific survey
  • eBay: You have feedback that you need to leave

Who knew that evaluation surrounded me each day…. I sure didn’t until I took the time to relate these things to what I’ve learned in my classes. When we first started reading about evaluation and all the different types of models there may be, I kept trying to think of ways it related to my life and my job. Well, here are just a few examples. One of these evaluations, the VCU Department of Business survey, which I still haven’t completed (I should do this) is optional. It states that I have been randomly selected to provide my feedback on areas such as retail bookstores, dining, parking and transportation, etc. The next survey I was asked to complete is for a service contract I purchased for equipment in the labs. I actually completed this one when I received it, mostly because it was work related and I have this fear that they may contact my boss if I don’t (not really, but I’ve found I’ll do surveys like this sooner because it’s work related.) Lastly, the eBay feedback survey… this one would be the last out of the three I would fill out. Probably because the product I purchased was a $4.99 IPhone gym case and I don’t know how much I can really say about it.

My only criticism about certain evaluation methods is that they need to apply to my situation if I’m going to respond. For instance, the Thermo Fisher survey listed about 10 questions and had the rankings of poor to outstanding for each, also including a N/A option. I had to put the N/A answer to most of the questions because I didn’t deal with any service technicians, quick response of getting the product or helpful purchasing staff. I ordered a service contract renewal and we don’t ever have to talk to the company because we do our ordering through eVA, VCU’s electronic purchasing system (the one I’ve spoken so highly about!!) Also, for the VCU Department of Business survey, the services somewhat pertain to me, but when they say that it will take 10 minutes or so, unfortunately I’m more likely to not complete it.

These seem like fairly typical problems evaluators and organizations have when they send out electronic surveys. Yes, they are inexpensive forms of evaluation, but I wonder just how many people do what I do and either A. ignore that they ever received it or B. clicks that delete button.

One response so far

Oct 15 2008

Field Interview: Program Planning through a Different Lens

Published by jennk under ADLT 602

Taking you back a few years, during my time as an undergrad here at VCU I took a marketing communications course. Our main project that semester was to pitch a program plan to local businesses around Richmond. One of the clients was Positive Vibe Cafe, a non-profit organization training and employing people with physical and developmental disabilities in food services. Needless to say, when I saw this assignment I immediately thought of Positive Vibe.

To maintain confidentiality, I will call my interviewee Ms. Cafe. She is the training program director for Positive Vibe Cafe and was kind enough to answer some of my questions:

1. What special considerations must you address when planning programs for your adult learners at Positive Vibe?

Since Positive Vibe works with individuals with disabilities, differentiation is vital when planning programs and training sessions for their adult learners. Each class session lasts four weeks with three weeks between each session. This period of time allows for interviewing candidates, scheduling volunteers and chefs, and adjusting the curriculum. Ms. Cafe stated that knowing each individuals reading ability, social level or any physical handicaps allows them to adjust lessons as needed. However, the classes are not grouped by disability or level of independence, so that has to be taken into consideration when planning lessons. They may have a class consisting of students in the autistic specturm, Down syndrome, Bi-polar, ADHD or emotionally disturbed. This means that the material must be presented and repeated in multiple learning models to ensure that each student receives and comprehends the information.

2. What are the greatest limitations and/or constraints you face when planning your program and training sessions at Positive Vibe? How do you deal with these issues?

Ms. Cafe strongly emphasized the word, scheduling. She said that at Positive Vibe they rely on multiple volunteers, staff and chefs to assist with instruction and student internships. This means she is correlating up to 20 different schedules, wow! She has found that preparation is the most important step to overcome this issue, as well as some flexibility. Before the training sessions, she sends out the dates for all possible internships to volunteers and requests that they let her know what days they are available. From here, she schedules the students’ internships (3 each consisting of both lunch and dinner). To ensure that she avoids a conflict with any particular student, Ms. Cafe asks for any schedule conflicts that they may have with interships during their interview. This helps to cut back on chances that the student may not make their scheduled internship. Once everything is finally in place, Ms. Cafe will send out weekly reminders to her students and intership supervisors to let them know who is schedules and on what day and time. This also helps to reduce the chances that a volunteer forgets or possibly double books themselves. She again emphasized that this takes time, but any conflicts are detected earlier and can hopefully be fixed before the day of the internship. She similarly does the same steps for both chefs and volunteers during class. Once she knows what days she has assistance during class, certain lessons that require more than one instructor are scheduled. Ms. Cafe said it’s important to maintain a good working relationship with the kitchen and its staff at the restaurant. “I never schedule cooking days on Tuesday though, when the restaurant opens for the week!”

3. Where do/did your idea for these programs and training internships come from? Are they dictated by administration/requested by learners/or are they needs you recognize that need to be addressed?

The training program was initially started due to Garth Lacen’s experience with his own son, Max, who suffers from Muscular Dystrophy. The mission of the program is to help those with disabilities find gainful employment within the community. Ms. Cafe stated that currently, individuals with disabilities suffer an astounding 70% unemployment rate. “By supplying individuals with the skills and experience we are giving them the opportunity to provide for themselves. Additionally, any individual with a disability who finds employment adds to public awareness and acceptance.”

4. What are some of the challenges you have faced in Positive Vibe’s programs or training and how have you overcome them?

Ms. Cafe again emphasized that the most common challenges are scheduling and differentiation of material. “Since one cannot anticipate exactly what obstacles or conflicts may occur, it helps to be overly prepared and flexible.” Occasionally volunteers will not be able to commit to their internship and advanced reminders usually remind them to let Ms. Cafe know so she can find a sub. She said she also over schedules her internship supervisors. Even if she doesn’t have a student scheduled for an hour they volunteered, she keeps record of what day it was just in case she has to reschedule a student or adds a student right before class begins. For the actual classes, Ms. Cafe said she comes prepared with multiple teaching methods and activities. If one doesn’t work, she will try another approach.

5. In your experience, what has been the most effective program/training session planned? What makes it or made it successful?

Given the amount of planning that is required to differentiate lessons for Positive Vibe learners, the more background information she has about each student the more successful the class. Knowing the abilities and limitations allows her to plan certain accomodations for each lesson. She stated that it’s just like any other classroom, there have to be clear expectations and goals. Since they have instituted a policy of “professionalism” to the sessions, she has seen better attention and attitudes during classes. They don’t have any behavioral systems in place, but discipline is key in learning and retention. “I explain that they are expected to act like professionals and if they cannot, they will be “fired” from the program. If a trainee’s conduct is called into question, Ms. Cafe will ask them to reflect on their behavior and answer the question, “was that professional?” Positive Vibe’s concept of professionalism in their training program serves the dual purpose of educating the students on social expectations. Given some of their students’ disabilities, social integration is also an important factor in the training program and is something they can take with them to any workplace. Finally, Ms. Cafe stated, “I personally feel that no matter the student’s age or subject matter, clear expecatations and outcomes must be given so that both parties are invested in goals, and motivated to accomplish them.”

What I found most insightful and important in this interview is that it doesn’t matter who the participants and audience are, when planning programs and training sessions the same criteria has to be followed. Positive Vibe has developed this special program that gives opportunities to adults with disabilities, and these adults may not have ever had the chance otherwise to get out into the work world. I am not aware of other training programs for adults with disabilities like Positive Vibe and was shocked when I heard that these individuals suffer 70% unemployment rate. Communication, flexibility, scheduling and also being professional are key and are stressed in this program, similiarly to other programs and models we’ve discussed. Overall, this interview was very enlightening and helped me pull together concepts and themes we’ve talked about this semester.

No responses yet

Oct 07 2008

Oh October.

Published by jennk under Everyday

It’s around this time of the year that I get into the mid-semester slump… I think that it’s fairly normal for any student to feel this way. The weather is changing and that “crisp” is in the air each morning that makes everyone want to stay in bed those few minutes longer. It’s around this time of the year that I want to take off work and take off school and take in each day to its fullest….. but back to reality. The difference this semester is that we were given this blogging experience to not only write about our class thoughts, readings and discussions, but we can also write about personal beliefs on our adult learning experiences.

I have a tendancy to stress myself out way in advance, over issues and situations that are beyond my control. I’ve been thinking a lot recently about my future and what my goals and aspirations are once I am done with school. I am learning to take a deep breath and realize that I have the best of all worlds right now. I’m in a learning situation with classmates and professors from different backgrounds and experiences that I absorb each week . My job allows me to interract with adult learners on a daily basis and I have quickly seen what works and what doesn’t for them, not only in my department, but within the school. I have a family that supports me and friends that understand I can’t go out every weekend… so, who knows where I will end up. Who knows what the future brings or what will happen in my career. I need to remind myself to keep learning from classmates and keep taking in everything I can through my job so one day, no matter where I end up, I will remember what I learned during my time here at VCU.

No responses yet